Sign Up for Our Newsletter and Get a FREE 30 Minute Meal eBook! SIGN UP HERE!

Nutter Butter Ice Cream

posted by Julie Evink on June 17, 2013

Nutter Butter Ice Cream ~ Creamy & Smooth Peanut Butter Ice Cream stuffed with Nutter Butters! via www.julieseatsandtreats.comI’m in love. I might even cheat on my hubby. It’s called Nutter Butter Ice Cream. Oh how I love thee. Creamy, Peanut Buttery, Smooth, Amazing.

Sinfully Delicious.

The wonderful people at KitchenAid sent me a Ice Cream Attachment for my beloved KitchenAid Stand Mixer to review and I fell in love. You see, before this I had one of those big old ice cream makers where you had to have ice and salt and it was a mess. Henceforth why I used it a whopping ONE time in 2 1/2 years. To much work. I had been drooling and coveting this little Ice Cream Attachment for a while and I might have even snuck it into my dreams that’s how bad I wanted it. And then I was blessed. Although my hips might disagree with that.

Let’s just say that in the three weeks we have had this beauty there have been three batches of ice cream made. My hubby BEGS for it and it’s so easy to make I agree. It’s easier that cookies peeps!

The bowl has a liquid built right in for you so no hassle with those messy ice cubes. You just need to make sure that bowl is frozen when you go to make the ice cream. Oh no you think I plan ahead? Heck no. I just keep that baby in the freezer all the time. You never know when you might NEED it. Yes NEED. Sometimes life is like that.


So then I just prepare my ice cream ingredients according to the recipe and then grab my bowl right out of the freezer and pop it into the base of my KitchenAid stand mixer. Attach the paddle, turn it on and pour in the ingredients. Ok, did you read that? Attach the paddle FIRST, then turn it on, and then pour in the ingredients. Now if you don’t do it like this you will have a mess. Not that I, of course, had that happen. Just trust me on this.


So then just let it stir for about 15 minutes or until you hear it clicking, take it out and it’s at a soft serve stage. The hubs loves this and eats it like this, but you can also stick in the freezer and let it set up a bit more. Whatever floats your boat!

Now I know you want to run out and buy that attachment right? Of course you do! It’s summer, you are dieing from the heat and ice cream obviously fixes all your problems in the world. Duh.


Make sure you don’t miss any of the fun stuff Julie’s Eats & Treats is up too!


Nutter Butter Ice Cream & $100 Amazon Giftcard Giveaway

Preparation 30 minutes


  • 2 cups of heavy cream
  • 1 cup of half and half
  • 3/4 cups of sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1/3 cup of peanut butter (creamy or smooth)
  • 1 c. Nutter Butter Cookies, coarsely chopped


  1. In a large mixing bowl combine, heavy cream, half and half, sugar and vanilla extract. Mix until well combined.
  2. Pour into ice cream maker and prepare according to according to directions.
  3. When ice cream is about half done add peanut butter by the spoonful.
  4. In the last few minutes mix in the cookies or add these at the end by hand.


Nutrition Facts
Serving Size
Amount Per ServingAs Served
Calories 3064kcal Calories from fat 2233
% Daily Value
Total Fat 248g382%
Saturated Fat 136g680%
Transfat 0g
Cholesterol 742mg247%
Sodium 297mg12%
Carbohydrate 193g64%
Dietary Fiber 4g16%
Sugars 183g
Protein 36g

Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs:

Total FatLess than65g
Sat FatLess than25g
CholesterolLess than300mg
SodiumLess than2,400mg
Total Carbohydrate300g
Dietary Fiber25g


Get your free eCookbook

Make sure you don’t miss any of the fun stuff Julie’s Eats & Treats is up to!

Follow AlongOn SnapcatRSS/SubscribeOn PinterestOn BloglovinOn InstagramOn TwitterOn FacebookOn YouTube
filed under Dessert, Desserts
tagged with ,


  • Tracey @ The Kitchen is My Playground

    Yum, Julie! That Nutter Butter ice cream looks dee-lish. I’m loving seeing what we all made for our ice cream-themed give-away. 🙂
    Tracey @ The Kitchen is My Playground

    • Julie Evink

      Thanks Tracey!! I love ice cream 🙂

  • Julianne J

    I would love to have the ice cream maker for my stand mixer. Thanks for the opportunity!

  • Amanda J

    I would love to get the ice cream maker attachment for my stand mixer. Thanks!

  • Maggie Wallace

    Yummo! Would love to have an ice cream maker!

  • Celeste

    I would get the ice cream maker attachment for my KitchenAid mixer — I have been wanting one forevah!!

  • kathy lee

    what fun to do with my grandkids, they love them some icecream!!!

  • Holly Wert

    i’d like to try the attachment too

  • sharonjo

    I would love to get The Perfect Scoop ice cream recipe book by David Lebovitz. Thanks so much!

  • tanya

    I have always wanted to try that attachment! I do have a pretty easy ice cream maker which we received 12 years ago as a wedding gift. I think to this day, it’s my favorite gift! I will HAVE to try this recipe! Nutter Butter are my favorite cookies of all time!

  • Erin @ The Spiffy Cookie

    Great ice cream flavor!

  • Rachael M.

    I would buy a really nice ice cream scooper, plus some fun color bowls in which to serve my favorite ice cream!

  • megan

    i LOVE nutter butters and so does my hubby… would never have thought to incorporate them into ice cream but this looks SO delicious!

  • Jen Nikolaus

    I want one of those attachments!! How COOL is that?!! And that ice cream. Oh my word. I would dream about that too. I must try this ASAP!!!!

    ~Jen @ Yummy Healthy Easy

  • Laura@bakinginpyjamas

    What a delicious ice cream. I love a scoop right now. I found your blog on Tuesday Talent Show.

  • Laura Dembowski

    I would buy ice cream cookbooks with my gift card. This ice cream sounds amazing! love pb and Nutter Butters! Totally agree that ice cream maker bowls should always be in the freezer!

  • Desi

    Ice cream cookbooks galore! I have a few already bookmarked that I want 🙂 And maybe some cute bowls!

  • Deirdre

    I’d get yummy syrups and cute ice cream dishes.

  • Jocelyn YES,PLEASE!! 😉

  • Mary.

    HI! Sorry you failed to mention, that this month, (june) is “national dairy month” How was the blogHER convention adventure? Was it fun? I love “nutterbutter cookies in this ice cream recipe. Can you modifiy this recipe a bit, to make a “low fat” version?

  • Kelly @ The Moon and Me

    Oh this sound sooo yummy! I just got an ice cream maker and have been looking for decadent recipes.

    • Julie Evink

      It’s pretty amazing if I do say so myself 🙂

  • Joan@Chocolate and More

    I need one of those attachments! But I think if I had one it might just be a bit too easy to make ice cream ALL the time! I’m loving your Nutter Butter Ice cream and just had to share it on my FB page today! Thanks for linking up at Thursday’s Treasures>

  • LB

    I would actually get that Kitchen Aid attachment! I have wanted one for so long!

  • Jess @HungryHarps

    A bag of Nutter Butters was calling my name at the store the other day – and I had the willpower to say no. However, I see I will be needing to go back and pick some up after all, because I just need this ice cream in my life!! I am pinning right now. 🙂 I would LOVE it if you would link this recipe up at Tasty Tuesdays!

    • Julie Evink

      You must head back to the store!!!

  • Carolsue

    I would buy an ice cream maker or a yogurt maker, I think!

  • Gwen

    the ice cream attachment for kitchenaid

  • Alex

    I love ice cream but hate eating the commercially processed stuff. I would love to make my own so easily!

  • Jenn

    I love homemade ice cream, and thanks to this post I’m going to be making some for my family tonight. 🙂

    If I won the $100 Amazon gift card I would use it to purchase the bookshelf headboard that I’ve been coveting since Christmas!

  • Sarah

    This recipe looks fabulous.. we love Nutter Butters! I would use a gift card for goodies for the family for summer.. and yeah, pretty sure that would include something for ice cream!

  • Katrina

    An Icecream Maker!

  • Karly

    Amazing ice cream, I want some right now! Thanks for linking up with What’s Cookin’ Wednesday!

  • Tamara H.

    I would love nutter butter ice cream…YUMMO!

  • Martha@A Family Feast

    This looks delicious Julie!! I haven’t had a nutter butter in ages and now you have my craving one… 🙂

    • Julie Evink

      It’s the weirdest craving I had during my pregnancy…and no I’m not preggers again!

  • Janeal Wilkerson

    I love ice cream and cookies too! I would also love the Amazon gift card……a way to get something I would like to have without having to “break the bank” to get it! LOL.

  • Paula

    When I start eating Nutter Butters I can’t stop, I know this would be fantastic. pinned.

    • Julie Evink

      I have the exact same problem! They are rarely allowed in my house!

  • Kris

    The Kitchen Aid Ice Cream Attachment

  • Shelley

    I would buy some fun ice cream bowls and The Perfect Scoop ice cream book!

  • Amanda Sakovitz

    I would love to get an ice cream maker. I love ice cream but it gets expensive to get anywhere besides the supermarket and homemade def tastes best

  • Thomas Murphy

    I would buy the Ice Cream Attachment

  • Mary.

    LOL! I love them too. You can get the “generic” version at the dollar tree® stores. 😉

  • Mary.

    I meant the cookies.

  • Nicole

    I just came upon your blog and I love it! Lots of great recipes. I’m kind of obsessed with ice cream – pinning this one for sure! Have a wonderful week 🙂

    • Julie Evink

      Welcome Nicole! Glad you found me 🙂

Leave a Comment

Your email is never shared.
Required fields are marked *